Those of you who said The Penelopiad by Margaret Atwood was a fast read weren’t kidding. I began reading it Monday on my lunch break. Read it Tuesday at lunch and then finished it last night. I stayed up a little past my bedtime to do it, but when I’m ten pages away from finishing a book it’s hard to go to bed.
The book tells the story of Penelope, Odysseus’s wife, from Penelope’s point of view. From her childhood rescue by ducks from drowning after her father threw her in to the water to try and circumvent a prophecy, to her arranged marriage with Odysseus (he cheated at a foot race against the other suitors), to her move to Ithaca, the Trojan war, and all that followed. The story is told in typical Atwood fashion with lots of wry humor. As an example of the humor are the reports of Odysseus Penelope receives from different quarters, there is the mythologized version and the other version:
Odysseus had been to the Land of the Dead to consult the spirits, said some. No, he’d merely spent the night in a gloomy old cave full of bats, said others. He’d made his men put wax in their ears, said one, while sailing past the alluring sirens–half-bird, half-woman–who enticed men to their island and then ate them, though he’d tied himself to the mast so he could listen to their irresistible singing without jumping overboard. No, said another, it was a high-class Sicilian knocking shop–the courtesans there were known for their musical talents and their fancy feathered outfits.
Interrupting Penelope’s story from time to time is a chorus interlude of the twelve maids that Odysseus had his son Telemachus hang for cavorting with the enemy. Their point of view doesn’t always agree with Penelope’s so they create a nice tension. And of course, they were hanged unfairly and call upon the Furies to exact punishment on Odysseus and to follow him “wherever he may take refuge, in songs and in plays, in tomes and in theses, in marginal notes and in appendices!” Atwood also uses the maids to poke gentle fun at the type of feminist analysis that turns female experience into goddess worship being destroyed by the patriarchy.
As you can tell, I very much enjoyed the book. This is no deep, literary Atwood book. This is Atwood having fun. But even having fun she still manages to say a few important things. It’s a quick and easy read, would be great for the beach if you want something light but not too light.
Terrific review and comments. I agree with you, it is Atwood sort of having fun. Tossing the Odyssey around much like a playful dolphin might bounce a ball on its nose. I enjoyed the book.
Like you say, a perfect read for the beach… of for otherwise utter relaxment [
Hey…. my comments got gibbled…. oh well. Sorry ’bout that. I was not even nearly finished blabbing!
I think everyone from the challenge has reviewed this book favorably. Plus, it’s got great cover art! I’ve been meaning to read Atwood for a while now, and this will probably be my introduction.
I agree it is a light book and a fast read. This could have been done better. Atwood ended up telling a fable and not a fiction , I was expecting. That was my disappointment after I finished reading.
I’m really looking forward to this. Atwood and a fabulous Greek myth – can’t really go wrong.
Just finishing the book myself, great fun. I’ve picked up another in this series: The Helmet of Horror by Victor Pelevin (the myth of Theseus and the Minotaur). Pelevin, for the uninitiated, is a Russian satirist and usually pretty funny; this story is set in internet chat rooms.
This sounds like fun! I’ve never read Atwood, and that’s a crime … I must get to that one of these days.
For a while now I’ve had the idea of authors doing “cover versions” of others works. I thought it would be a lot of fun to hear say Margaret Atwood’s version of “Carrie”. Needless to say, when this came out, I was more than pleased. However, I still haven’t gotten around to it. Your great review hopefully will put a fire under me.
I’ve also not read any Atwood yet, but I plan on remedying that next month as I will be reading at least one of her books for the Book Awards Challenge. I’m always reading a lot about her books so I definitely ready to see what all the fuss is about.
I liked this one a lot. I don’t know how it compares to her others, though, because the only other Atwood I’ve read is “Bluebeard’s Egg”, and it was a long time ago. I need to read more of her work.
Haven’t read this Atwood, but love many of her others. I’ve been meaning to read this for a long time – maybe I will now.
As an Atwood fan, I bought this in hardback when it first came out, but I kept selecting other books from the TBR pile instead of this one. I think I have to move this one to the top of the pile. If it’s as fast a read as you say, I might even be able to read it before I read my next book club selection.
Glad you enjoyed it! I thought it was a good one – I read it over a couple of days around christmastime, it suited the rather fantastical mood of that time of year! I love the whole concept of the Canongate Myths series. I also recommend ‘Weight’ by Jeanette Winterson which was top too. I have the others published so far on my ever growing TBR pile!
Speaking of TBR piles and lists, as I think someone recently was, this one sounds like it definitely belongs on mine.
Sorry your comment got eaten Cip, I know it was brilliant. Playful definitely catches some of the flavor of the book.
Kim, the coverart of the book is great. And it would be a good introduction to Atwood too.
Jayan, sorry to hear you were a bit disappointed with the book. I didn’t have any expectations, so maybe that made a difference.
Litlove, you’re right, it’s like chocolate and peanut butter, two good things that go great together.
Avaland, I have Helmet of Horror simply because it’s in the myth series, had no idea what it’s about but now I’m going to have to dig it out!
Dorothy, you’ve never read Atwood? You must remedy that as soon as you possibly can!
John, I like you “cover version” idea. This book definitely is something like it.
Matt, you won’t be disappointed when you get to reading Atwood next month.
Nymeth, I haven’t read all of Atwood but I have read a goodly amount, and this one fits in nicely. Not as complex as her other work, but just as well written.
Sheila, this one is worth the time, and what a smal bit of time it takes too.
Kim, it is a very fast read and I am a slow reader so I was suprised to finish it so quickly.
Jem, it would be good to read at Christmastime. Thanks for the tip on Weight. It’s in my TBR pile somewhere!
Ah, Emily, you’d enjoy this one, I’m sure of it.
You describe the book really well. It was a fun read–not too heavy and not too light. I also really enjoyed it, but I think Jayan sort of describes what I felt. I think I was expecting a sort of novel when really it is just a loose retelling of a myth. I always felt sort of distanced from Penelope, but I think now Atwood meant it to be that way. I would like to read more myths in this series and see how they compare.
I know what you mean about Penelope’s distance. It was a rather unemotional telling of the story. I’ve got several of the other myth books in the series and am looking forward to reading them.
Pingback: minotaur