What better thing to do last night after the snow shoveling and school work were done than to play with my new Kindle? I had finished the manual the night before and I was rarin’ to go. With Emily and Dorothy reviewing Gaudy Night recently I looked up Dorothy Sayers and the only sample I could get was from a nonfiction book she wrote called Are Women Human? The sample downloaded before I could blink. Unfortunately, the sample had none of the text, only a picture of the book cover, the colophon and the table of contents. Fine then. I didn’t want to read samples anyway, I want to read whole books.
That gave me a chance to try out manybooks.net. I went to the mobile version which fit perfectly on the Kindle screen, and poked around. So much to choose from! I chose The Letters of Ralph Waldo Emerson and Thomas Carlyle, because what could be more fitting for my first Kindle book? But before I got to reading, I went to Feedbooks and downloaded their catalog. It’s a big document and took almost a minute to download but what I get is offline book searching and when I find a book I want, I just click the link and it downloads. Free! What could be easier?
Now for the reading. I read for an hour and my eyes did not get tired at all. In fact, after a little while I forgot I was holding a Kindle and not a book. The only thing that takes getting used to is the way the pages “turn.” It doesn’t scroll or instantly change like a computer screen. The e-ink has to re-form itself into the new letters so you get a sort of “flash” effect and the page appears in negative and then the new page is on the screen. It is weird and freaked out my eyes the first couple of times but after a few pages I didn’t notice it as much.
I tried out the highlighting feature and love it. When you highlight something in a book, Kindle saves it to a special folder called “My Clips” with a sort of annotation so you know where it came from. So, for instance, I highlighted two things in the Emerson letters. If I want to see what they are I can page through the book but that is not really convenient. If I remember enough keywords I can do a search. Or, even better, I can go to the clips folder and there they are. Once I get lots of clips in there though I am not sure that it will be any more efficient than the other two methods. There must be some way to sort them or something. At least I hope there is.
I have yet to try out bookmarking or writing marginalia. I haven’t tried having a PDF or other document converted for reading on Kindle either. I’ll get to those eventually. But so far, so good on the Kindle experience.
My Bookman has not yet given it a test drive. His work schedule has been weird of late. But this morning as we saw each other in passing he showed me a great surprise. He has an ARC of Carlos Ruiz Zafon’s new book! A box of advanced readers arrived in the bookstore office the other day and no one had opened it so he opened it last night and got first dibs. He had the day off today. I told him I expected I would come home to him sobbing as he turned the final page. He said he is going to read the book slowly and savor it. And what do you know, he didn’t even open it today. He has far greater discipline than I would have in the same situation.
The Kindle Test Drive
27 Friday Feb 2009
Advertisement
Ooo, lucky you to get a ARC of the Zafon book–even if you have to wait to read it. You’ll have to let us know what you (or your Bookman) thinks! What book are you going to read first on your Kindle and how are you dividing up time to use it? Have fun experimenting with it.
I have had my Kindle since Thanksgiving – and actually just wrote a review of it tonight. I had not heard of the feedbooks guide however, and have just downloaded it. Thanks so much for that wonderful suggestion.
Unbeknownst to first-time user, the flash effect does sound a bit scary. But the Kindle seems to be a very reliable and “eye-friendly” device. Does it remember where you stop reading?
Very lucky to have an advanced copy of that book! I would definitely have to open it straight away I think. Looking forward to hearing all about it.
Thanks for the report! I wonder if they will try to improve the page-turning experience in future versions — that’s something I can see people being a bit unhappy with. But everything else sounds great. I’m curious about bookmarking and marginalia — those seem important things to keep the experience as close to book-reading as possible.
Wow, sounds like fun. I have been sort of anti-Kindle (just because I am very pro-paper-book) but this does sound pretty neat, especially for travelling and such. I’ll be curious how you end up using it and what you think after a couple of months.
I think I would like to have a Kindle for reading all my journal articles for the university… but I really don’t think I could take it if the gadget decides to run out of battery..
What happens if in a year the battery is no longer as lasting? Like the iPods, you begin with super long life batteries but as the years go by it charges less and less… what happens to all the books? Can you back them up?
I read Carlos Ruiz Zafon’s new book this week.. I read it in spanish… your bookman won’t be disappointed!
How interesting. I can see the kindle being really good for research writing and all school or business work. I’m not convinced I’d want to read a whole novel on it, but still, it is encouraging if you are loving it. And I’m most intrigued as to what CRZ has written next – looking forward to that review!
Hi Stefanie, I’m a great fan of Feedbooks because they get their formatting right, offer multiple e-formats, and answer all email questions promptly and precisely. And they will be serialising my new novel Corvus too! (You can read Mortal Ghost from there too.)
Since I don’t own an e-reader yet (can’t afford one), I’m glad to read your impressions.
I’m curious, how is the Read-To-Me feature that some publishers are upset about?
I have the earlier version of the kindle, and I’m enjoying mine, too. I easily got used to reading on it–my eyes don’t get tired, either. Initially I used to hit the “next page” button by accident, but fortunately that’s easy to undo. I have used the marking feature, as well, but I find scrolling through the book is a pain in the neck. And I also find that it’s hard to get used to physically not knowing where you are in the book. Yes, there are those dots at the bottom of the page, and the “locations” reference numbers, but it’s just not the same as page numbers. Does this bug you at all?
Danielle, I can’t believe how lucky I am with the Zafon book. My first Kindle book is the Correspondence of Thomas Carlyle and Ralph Waldo Emerson. I have already downloaded several other books to choose from after that!
Molly, and what a great review you wrote at that! Enjoy feedbooks. One more source of free books is a good thing
Matthew, yes, it does remember where you stopped reading which is very nice. And I am getting used to the flash. I hardly notice it now.
Karen, the ARC was a complete and very happy surprise. I’ll be reading it when my Bookman is done with it and will be sure to post about it.
Dorothy, I think as e-ink technology improves so will the page turning. I tried out the marginalia yesterday and it works great. It puts a little hyperlinked footnote number in the text and when you click on the number the note appears at the bottom of the screen. I have not yet bookmarked an entire page so don’t know how that works yet.
Daphne, it will be nice when the cover arrives and I get to try it out on public transit. Then I think it will truly shine.
Isolde, the battery lasts a long time, but yes, like laptop and ipod batteries it will eventually need to be replaced. I think a replacement battery is something like $65 but I won’t need to find out for sure for a few years. And yes, the Kindles have a special account at Amazon where all the books you buy are backed up. It doesn’t back up your free stuff or the personal documents you put on it, but you can back those up, as well as the Kindle books, on your computer. And nice to know the Zafon book won’t disappoint!
Litlove, it does seem like it will be convenient for travel especially since you can take books and personal documents on it with you and not have to take a whole laptop to read those pdfs, etc. And so far my husband is loving the CRZ book!
Lee, that’s great info to know about feedbooks. And I will have to look your book up there!
Colin, the text to speech works amazingly well. The page even turns to follow along with the speech. You can make it read faster or slower and choose from a male voice or a female voice. The voices are definitely computer voices though and of course there is no emotion or inflection in the reading. But for moments when you don’t want to put the book down but have to cook dinner, it will do in a pinch. I wouldn’t want to listen to an entire book using the feature.
Gentle Reader, apparently they have moved the buttons so the accidental page turning doesn’t happen anymore but even if it does it is, as you say, very easy to undo. I discovered that all of my highlighted items are viewable from within the book by click a link to “my marks and annotations.” It shows me what I have marked in that book only and its location number, no need for scrolling! Whew! I’m not so bugged by not being able to see where I am in the book. I find I am fascinated with the little percentage finished display though.
I think the “flash” effect you mentioned would probably take a bit of getting used to but otherwise it all sounds so fun. I want one!
And, of course I’m jealous of Mr. Bookman’s ARC! I saw an interview of Carlos Ruiz Zafon on one of the Spanish language tv stations a couple of weeks ago and it was interesting to find out some tidbits about him.
Anyway, continue to enjoy the Kindle!
I’m still holding out on e-books, possibly somewhat futilely, but it’s good to hear some other thoughts and reviews of the Kindle device…sounds pretty good really, though it pains me to say that.
It’s funny how the world of literature is starting to hit the changes that the music industry felt with the advent of mp3s…I’m not e-books will ever take over quite in the same way but it’s interesting to see them progress.
I’ve also noticed more and more sites such as this one cropping up across the web which are taking note of the waves – some look quite good, and will most probably take on the wave of e-books when they begin to spread. No doubt amazon will take the lead as normal though!
Iliana, the flash did take some getting used to but I hardly notice it now. I think you would very much enjoy the Kindle especially on your trips to Germany. Carlos Ruiz Zafon is an interesting man, isn’t he? I heard him do a reading of Shadow of the Wind just before it become so popular.
hannah, I don’t imagine e-book readers will replace paper books, but they are a nice addition to the reading arsenal. And a good comparison between the music and book industry. How copyright issues are going to be dealt with will be very interesting to watch. Thanks for the link!
Sounds like the Kindle is thus far an awesome experience! You mentioned PDFs — does Kindle read pdf format? That makes it remarkably more useful if it’s not just the proprietary format.
I may have to give in and do the Kindle thing someday.
Oh this is so good to read. I’m debating the kindle since I travel so much and it would be a good thing to take in my bag instead of eighty novels. I’m glad you are enjoying it!
I am slowly wearing down on the idea of a kindle. I’m glad to hear they don’t tire the eyes- that is my main worry. And the highlighting feature sounds really cool!
Rebecca, so far, so good! You have to send your pdf file to Amazon for it to be converted. You can have it converted for free and sent back to you to upload manually to the Kindle or you can pay ten cents for the convenience of downloading it directly. Apparently the conversion works great on pdfs that are mostly text but not so great on highly formatted ones with lots of graphics.
Verbivore, oh yes, it would make a huge difference when traveling. Unfortunately Kindles are only available in the US at the moment which seems completely silly to me.
Jeane, it took me a long time to consider an e-book reader but it is turning out to be pretty nifty!
Have you heard of a blog called Bookyards? It’s on blogspot.com. I think it could be of interest to you and you kindle thingy…
Em, I have not heard of that blog. I will check it out. Thanks!