I read Sea of Poppies by Amitav Ghosh because it was Grad’s absolute favorite book last year and she repeatedly raved about it. Grad being one smart woman I was curious about the book. And now I understand why Grad had so many glowing things to say about it.
You need to know that Sea of Poppies is the first book of a trilogy. This bit of information will keep you from being worried about the slow pace of the first two-thirds of the book. Ghosh spends that time creating a large cast of fascinating characters and firmly rooting us in Colonial India and the opium trade. The book is a lesson in the prejudice, the cruelty, the politics and economics that served the whites and eroded the well-being of the Indians. On the edges is the British trade with China, the British pretty much forcing their illegal opium into the Chinese market and even whispering about war when China starts to crack down.
The language was a bit difficult at first. There is quite a lot of pidgin English and shipboard slang to get used to. Sometimes the characters in the book didn’t understand each other either and the miscommunications produced humor as well as trouble.
I had been happily reading the book during my lunch breaks at work and on my short train commute. But when I got to the final third of the book last Friday and things started happening, I couldn’t wait for Monday and I finished the book in one big gulp Saturday evening. It has a cliffhanger ending but far from making me mad, as cliffhangers generally do, it served to make me want to read more. So I wait with excitement for book two.
What I really liked about the book was the characters. They were all so different and so interesting in their own ways. We know more about some than others, and we watch as a good many of them put on masks to hide who they really are. But there are some characters who, towards the end, begin to allow others to see behind the mask. As Paulette says to Zachary Reid:
‘Are not all appearances deceptive, in the end? Whatever there is within us – whether good, or bad, or neither – its existence will continue uninterrupted, will it not, no matter what the drape of our clothes, or the colour of our skin? What if it is the world that is a duperie, Mr. Reid, and we the exceptions to its lies?’
The quote makes it sound like there is moralizing, but there is nothing of the sort. This is pretty much the only thing said on the subject and it comes very late in the book and by that point, if you have been reading carefully, Paulette is just saying what you already know.
Somehow I don’t feel like I have given the book any sort of justice. There isn’t really a plot, though things happen. Lots of things happen. But this book is all about the characters, well drawn and varied. I am really interested to see what Ghosh does with the second book, whether it will have more plot since the setting and characters are already established. I’ll have to wait and see.
I have been meaning to read this book for ages. I am currently participating in the South Asian reading challenge, and I am thinking of picking this one.
I generally like all books of a trilogy/series to complete before I start reading though. I hate waiting for the next book in a series to get published…
Nice review
Stefanie, you did far more justice to the book that I was ever able to. Funny, I hadn’t thought of it before, but you are absolutely correct…the book – at least this first volume -is mostly about the characters (with a great deal of plot development). And although there were numerous story lines, and the dialect was challenging at times, Ghosh always made it interesting. I wanted to know more about these characters and what was going to happen to them. I am thinking that once we get into the second trilogy there will be a lot of opium drama and Casablanca-esque intrigue. I check at least once a month to see if there’s any word on when we can expect it. I am so anticipating that! This was the first Ghosh I read. Wow, what a writer. I just checked The Glass Palace out of the library and hope to start it this week after I finish Red Harvest by Dashiell Hammett. Great post, Stef (and I thank you for your sweet compliment.)
I’m not sure what to think about this book? Guess I will have to read it and see. I own it so perhaps I’ll get to it soon.Thanks for the honest review.
I didn’t know it was a trilogy…I don’t think I’m prepared for that.
I enjoyed this book a great deal too. It took me a while to get into it, but once I did (at about the halfway point) I was enthralled. Alas, I understand that it might be a while (years) until the next book comes.
Stefanie, you make me look to my shelf yonder!
I have had Ghosh’s earlier book The Glass Palace on my bookshelf for years and years. Have not read the thing.
If Sea of Poppies was this good, maybe I should blow the dust off The Glass Palace soon…
I like the idea of taking a long time to establish the characters. What’s the rush, right? I wouldn’t like it that the next book in the trilogy isn’t out, though. It would be hard to wait to see how the cliffhanger turns out!
Sounds terrific. I’ll have to add it to the TBR tome. Sigh!
Huh! Just went to Goodreads and discovered I already have it in the TBR tome. See why I have to keep these lists?
What a great review of this book. I absolutely LOVED this book…and can’t wait until the next one in the trilogy is released. I thought that the language really worked once I got used to it; and I also didn’t mind the build up with the character development. Like you, I consumed the last third of the book almost without taking a break!
Great review-I liked this book a lot-it has kind of an old fashioned feel to it like a novel from the 19th century-I do found all the new to me terminology from the era a slowing down factor at first but I got past it-I will be very eager to read the next two parts of the trilogy.
Lovely review of a book I hadn’t really been tempted by. My response to dialect in language is unpredictable – sometimes I literally cannot bear it. But you make it sound very interesting, so I won’t rule it out completely!
I loved it, too! I actually loved the language most of any aspect of the book, but you’re right that the characters are very compelling. Waiting with you for the next in the trilogy…!
I didn’t know it was going to be part of a trilogy – tricky authors keep making me stumble into new series. Great review, keep hearing things about the difficult language so I’m glad to hear you say you can get into it and it’s not a barrier to enjoying the book.
Nish, thanks! I prefer it when all the books of a trilogy are out before embarking too. But I wanted to see what this one was about and now I’m hooked and waiting, waiting, waiting for book two!
Grad, nah, you did great too! Ghosh did keep things interesting. I wonder if he outlined the book before writing it since so much is intertwined by the end? I suspect you are right, the next book will have much more plot, but I hope it doesn’t lose the character focus too much. You’ll have to post on you blog what you think of Glass Palace because I am curious about it now.
Diane, it’s good. I am still thinking about it and have moments of missing it. Don’t be turned of by the language at first. The effort will pay off.
softdrink, heh, yes, you must be prepared to be sucked in to three books before you start this one. But since this is the only one currently out, you’ll get a break between them.
Teresa, years before the next book? Noooo! That is just not right. Do you think he’ll write faster if we send him pestering emails?
Cip, I’ve not read Glass Palace but given Sea of Poppies is so good, I’d expect Glass Palace to be pretty terrific too.
Dorothy, the characters are all so interesting that it was marvelous watching them develop. It was fun not to rush. I am now very anxious for the next book but I have no choice except to be patient.
Emily B, heh, that’s pretty funny that it turned out to be on your list already. I’ve added books to my lists too that I had already added, so don’t feel bad
Wendy, it’ a good one isn’t it? Even though the language was hard to get used to at first I wouldn’t want it written any differently. Ghosh had better hurry up with the second book!
Mel u, thanks! I know what you mean about the old fashioned feel. I does have that quality to it and I think it makes the reading even more pleasurable.
Litlove, so I worked some magic and made you tempted? Maybe by the last book I’ll get you to plunge in
Emily, once I got used to the language it was enjoyable and fascinating. It added so much to the characters and to the atmosphere.
Jodie, I know, darn those authors!
Oh yes, after an initial adjustment to the language you can definitely get into it.
Pingback: Review: Sea of Poppies, Amitav Ghosh « Jenny's Books