It is so beautiful here today, 73 degrees (F) above zero, that I am tempted to chuck the blog and go revel in the warm outside. The one thing that is stopping me is that it is pretty windy out and I don’t want to mess up my perfect hair. The windy part is true at any rate.
Elizabeth and Her German Garden by Elizabeth von Arnim (also known as Mary Annette Beauchamp and a cousin of Katherine Mansfield), was published in 1898. I had thought it was fiction but it turns out to be a sort of memoir in a diary format the goes from May to April. But the dated entries are only meant to serve as loose indications as to the time of year rather than strict XYZ happened today. In fact von Arnim ranges all over, forward and backward through time so that when April and the end of the book arrive it feels as though a good number of years have been covered.
Von Arnim has such a light and happy voice that makes her a pleasure to read. Ostensibly, the book is about her garden in Germany at the old house she convinced her husband, referred to throughout as The Man of Wrath, to allow her to fix up and rescue the garden. But Elizabeth is a novice gardener who makes lots of mistakes. But mistakes, as all gardeners know, are opportunities to learn and do better the next year. While Elizabeth is disappointed by her mistakes, she always manages to see the bright side of things and how beautiful her garden is and how much more lovely it will become.
The house is in a small German village. She finds her neighbors amusing and they find her, well, I’ll let her tell you:
The people round about are persuaded that I am, to put it as kindly as possible, exceedingly eccentric, for the news has travelled that I spend the day out of doors with a book, and no mortal eye has yet seen me sew or cook. But why cook when you can get someone to cook for you? And as for sewing, the maids will hem the sheets better and quicker than I could, and all forms of needlework of the fancy order are inventions of the evil one for keeping the foolish from applying their heart to wisdom.
I was disappointed to find out that von Arnim doesn’t actually do any of the work of the garden herself. Women of her station were apparently not allowed to dig in the dirt. So while she may be eccentric, she is not eccentric enough to flout this restriction and get blisters on her hands from a spade. All she does is choose the plants and tell the men she hires where to put them.
While I loved all the talk about gardening – and this being spring and the crocuses showing their tiny faces and the tulips shooting up their green leaves and me anticipating the May plant sale catalog to arrive at any moment – my favorite part of the book is a long section in the winter where she has her friend Irais and a woman named Minora whom another friend asked her to invite for a visit. Minora is young and English and wants to be a writer and thinks Elizabeth and her family will make great copy. She is forever scribbling notes in her notebook. Elizabeth and Irais are constantly making fun of Minora and telling her things about Germany and German families that are exaggerations or simply not true. But Minora takes everything seriously and is so gullible she falls for everything they say. And then they go on a winter picnic to the Baltic, a sleigh ride of a couple hours. Oh, how it made me laugh!
Winter ends, her guests leave, and Elizabeth is left to her books and her garden again. She concludes:
I do sincerely trust that the benediction that is always awaiting me in my garden may by degrees be more deserved, and that I may grow in grace, and patience, and cheerfulness, just like the happy flowers I so much love.
It’s so sugary it is almost too much, but the book is so lighthearted and enjoyable that by the time I reached the end I sighed in happiness instead of gagged.
A pleasant book, perfect for spring. I downloaded the book for free for my Kindle- it’s public domain – from ManyBooks. If you are interested in reading it on an electronic device, check it out, the download formats are numerous and sure to meet your requirements.
I LOVE this book! I love the Man of Wrath, love Irais… had forgotten about Minora altogether… I really enjoy Elizabeth von Arnim’s writing, novels and nonfiction. Her life makes very interesting reading, have you seen the only biography of her that I know of (out of print I believe): Elizabeth of the German Garden by Leslie deCharmes.
Oh… love this so much. “But why cook when you can get someone to cook for you? And as for sewing, the maids will hem the sheets better and quicker than I could, and all forms of needlework of the fancy order are inventions of the evil one for keeping the foolish from applying their heart to wisdom.”
Of course!
I love her too and can’t wait to read this.
I love, love, love this book. Whenever people ask for recommendations, this is one of the first I give. So glad you enjoyed it!
I downloaded this awhile back, after you mentioned the freebie von Arnims for the Kindle. It sounds as if I should squeeze this one in before I read another freebie Anthony Trollope!
Lol – it IS sugary!! So is The Enchanted April (my mother gave it back to me half-read saying ‘FAR too happy for me, dear’). But I do think she always pulls it off because she is funny and has really annoying friends and manages to sail over the top of disapproval and disaster.
I sometimes pretend not to like sugary books, but the truth is that if they are done well, I enjoy them a lot. It sounds like this one is done very well, and I’m hoping to read Von Arnim at some point. I will begin with The Enchanted April and maybe get to this one eventually. How fun to read this right as spring is just beginning and gardening season is about to start!
I really liked this one when I read it, and it seems there is another book that is a sequel to it that I should read as well, but my favorite is The Enchanted April–it’s just such a happy, pleasant book and sometimes you really need those!
“But why cook when you can get someone to cook for you?” – Oh I love that! haha…
I’ve only read her book Enchanted April which is an all-time favorite but don’t know why I’ve not read anything else by her. Must remedy that!
I’m so glad you reviewed this book! It’s been on my PaperBackSwap wish list for over a year, but I don’t know much about it. Your review encouraged me to keep waiting for a copy, thanks!
You know, while there is a happy sugari-ness to her, I think there is a wickedness that lies beneath. She’s cheeky, she plays with us, teases us a little … that’s why I like her so much. Underneath it all are some truths about women’s lives that she knows full well I think …
A really fun book of hers is her “this is not an autobiography” book All the dogs of my life (which really is, in many ways, an autobiography – told through the stories of the various dogs she has owned). If you like dogs, in particular, you are sure to like Von Arnim on them!
Melanie, I didn’t know there was a biography! Looks like my library doesn’t have it but it is available through interlibrary loan. Thanks for letting me know about it. I will have to request it after I read a few more of her books.
Daphne, isn’t that great? I think you will enjoy the book when you get the chance to read it. So much fun and wonderfully comforting.
Claire, it was a pleasure from start to finish. I think I am going to have to read at least one von Arnim every spring/summer until I’ve read them all and then start over again
Susan, oh yes, you definitely need a break from Trollope
Litlove, you are right, Enchanted April was sugary too. But as you say, she manages to pull it off because of the humor and the annoying friends. Now if we could only all of us make such good use of our annoying friends!
Dorothy, I know exactly what you mean about pretending! I think you will love Enchanted April whenever it is you get to it.
Danielle, there is a sequel to this one? Fun! I liked Enchanted April more too, the characters in it were so delightful. German Garden has its moments though.
Iliana, isn’t it great? I follow that religiously
This is my second von Arnim, Enchanted April being the first, but I am looking forward to reading more as I suspect they are all delightful.
Laura, yay! It is an enjoyable book. I hope you get a copy soon and enjoy it. If you can’t wait, you can read the book for free online!
whisperinggums, I think you are right about the wickedness. It is not mean, more mischievous than anything. I will have to find All the Dogs. It sounds like one I will love! Thanks for letting me know about it!
Pingback: Elizabeth and her German Garden by Elizabeth von Arnim « The Sleepless Reader