I’ve been working my way through Hermione Lee’s Edith Wharton since the end of December 2009 and finally I have finished it. Don’t let how long it took me to read it make you think the book isn’t very good, far from it, this book is most excellent. My drawn out reading had everything to do with me and nothing to do with the book. Well, expect that the book is huge–762 pages in my hardcover edition.
Lee is a thorough biographer and a good writer. She must have ate, slept and breathed nothing but Wharton while she was researching and writing this book. The book is full to bursting with the facts of Wharton’s life but Lee turns them into a finely detailed portrait rather than a recitation of dates and a list of acquaintances. Lee has also read everything Wharton ever wrote and interweaves the creation of the books and stories with a fine literary analysis. While it is tempting to find the writer’s life in her fiction, Lee is very cautious about such an approach. She recognizes the influences from Wharton’s life that appear in the fiction but she does not speculate or read into plots and characters anything beyond the story itself.
Wharton had a long and fascinating life. She was a strong woman with definite opinions. She struggled to get out of “old New York” and its customs that oppressed women but ironically she disliked feminism and feminists. I have always thought of Wharton as a very rich woman, and she was wealthy, no doubt about it, but a large portion of her wealth was created by her success as a writer.
While she didn’t have to write for a living she did have to write in order to sustain her lifestyle. Thus she always struggled to find a balance between writing for the art and writing for the money. She did believe that she should be able to write for the art and be well paid and frequently grew frustrated by publishers and magazines that said her work was too intellectual and asked her to change her stories to better suit a more popular audience.
Aside from writing Wharton was quite the decorator and gardener. She loved to travel especially by car. And of course she read. A lot. By her late sixties she had about four thousand books divided between her two houses in France. Her book collection was not for looks. Her books were read and reread and marked up. She insisted books were meant to be used. Of course her library contained plenty of fiction and it had an international range. There was a large number of French fiction, English, Greek and Latin in translation, Italian and German (Goethe was a favorite). In addition to fiction she read poetry (she loved Walt Whitman), philosophy, essays, history, lives of saints and histories of religion. She had books on evolution, astronomy, popular science, gardening, and her battered Baedekers and Blue Guides.
Wharton comes across as a woman who lived life to the fullest. She was writing and making plans almost right up to the end when she had several strokes and her heart finally gave out. I am pretty sure I would have been terrified to be in the same room as Wharton, she could be rather imperious at times, but she was also shy in company she didn’t know well.
I am very glad to have read this biography. After the length of time it took me, I would have thought I’d want to be done with all things Wharton for a very long time. On the contrary, I have a very large desire to delve into Wharton’s work, especially her short stories and her lesser known novels. And Ethan Frome I really want to read that one. I have only seen the movie with Liam Neeson in it and I liked it very much. Now I just have to figure out a way to fit Wharton into my reading schedule.
I just finished Hermoine Lee’s also very long biography of Virginia Woolf-it is a truly great literary biography -I enjoyed your post a lot-I also read the Wharton bio a few years ago!
Good review. A good biographer of a writer makes you want to read that writer. Your review makes me want to read Lee’s book and I’m sure that will make me want to read more Wharton.
I am so impressed that she wrote so many biographies! As the previous commenter mentioned, Virginia Wolff also. How does one writer get such a passionate biography written for so many different authors! Amazing. Anyway, I love biographies, and it sounds like Lee is definitely the biographer to read.
PS Ethan Frome is VERY SHORT. You can read it very quickly some wintery snowy afternoon as it’s perfect for winter.
I’ve been wanting to read a good bio on Wharton for some time now. This sounds like just the one! Adding it to that looooong Must Get list.
That sounds like an excellent bio. I’ve been more into biographies lately. I haven’t ever read Wharton, although I assume I must have read passages in English classes somewhere along the line…
I gave this book to my mum sometimes ago – with the hope that I would read it too, one day, but I haven’t got to it yet.
I really like what you say about Lee not reading Wharton’s life from her fiction. I think it’s more valid to see “the influences from Wharton’s life that appear in the fiction” but problematical to come back the other way, much as many biographers of writers would like to.
Ethan Frome was the first of hers that I read and it inspired me to read more. I’ve now read about 7 novels/novellas as well as a couple of short stories.
I have that biography, but haven’t more than dipped my toe into it. One of these days…but I have read a good bit of Wharton’s work within the last few years, and Ethan Frome was the first. If you like audio books, there is an *excellent* free audio of Ethan Frome at Librivox.org . It’s read by Elizabeth Klett, who is a literature professer and amateur thespian. Her reading is top-notch, and I’ve listened to books I didn’t care about, just because she read them. Wharton is one of her special interests, so she has done several of them for librivox. My most recent read was Age of Innocence this past spring/summer–the one that brought her the Pulitzer. I really need to get to the biography, too…
I keep hovering over this book, trying to decide whether to get it or not. I find Wharton fascinating, and her place in the history of literature is also really interesting too. But I know I hesitate to pick up huge biographies. Great review, Stefanie, and if anyone will swing it for me, you will!
You’ve made Edith Wharton and this book sound so interesting. I liked your paragraph about what she liked to do besides writing, because it gives a fuller picture her life. Don’t we all like to catch the famous doing ordinary things (in a nice way, not in a Hello magazine, omg she is going for coffee without brushing her hair kind of way). It was interesting to read her final novel The Buccaneers because that was one of the last big plans she was making I guess and had produced really detailed plans for it.
Pingback: Edith Wharton, A journey « Whispering Gums
I find Wharton and her time period fascinating. Of course, her friendship with Henry James and her gardening also pique my interest in the woman whose books are now classics! Delving into the lives of authors you like is especially fun when you get an idea of a different age and society.
Mel, I read the Woolf bio quite a few years ago and thought it really amazing and so much better than the Quentin Bell bio. Lee is a top notch biographer.
Bob, thanks! I think you are right, a good bio does make you want to read the writer. I hinestly wasn’t all that interested in Wharton when I began reading it and now I want to gobble up everything she wrote.
Rebecca, thanks for the tip on Ethan Frome. I think it might make perfect reading over my winter holiday vacation at the end of December. As far as Lee goes, she is so good she could write about anybody or anything and I would read her.
Inkslinger, if you want to read a bio on Wharton you can’t go wrong reading this one.
Daphne, if you read this bio you will definitely want to read Wharton. I haven’t read much of her but now I find myself wanting to read everything.
whisperinggums, I hate it when biographers read an author’s life from the fiction, drives me nuts. So I really appreciated Lee’s careful approach. I think it is time you borrow the book from your mum and dive in
Krakovianka, thanks for the tip on the audiobooks and the excellent reader. I will definitely look them up!
Litlove, I know it is a chunky book but it is fascinating and well written and I am certain that if you do decide to read it you will enjoy it.
Jodie, Wharton was a very interesting woman and I love learning about her. Wharton was such a busy person sometimes I found myself wondering when did she have time to write? She was a voracious learner and was always open to knew experiences and ideas. It is unfortunate she died before she finished The Buccaneers. I think it would have been one of her greatest novels if not the greatest.
Jenclair, it was a fascinating time. Her friendship with James looms large in her life and in the biography but it seems like her energy was sometimes too much for James to bear. But then her energy was often too much for most of her friends. and I got tired sometimes just hearing about what traveling with her was like!
Congratulations on finally finishing this! Didn’t you love the whole chapter devoted to her library and the markings-up in her books?
I’m a huge fan of Lee and agree with everything you say here, and particularly appreciate Lee’s subtlety in analyzing biographical influences on fiction while maintaining a cautiousness about over-identifying fictional characters with author. I keep meaning to pick up her Cather bio.
I have never read Wharton. There I said it. I’m sure people reading this comment are aghast! But if it helps, your review has made me want to read Wharton and then this one about her.
Kathleen! I am shocked! Shocked, I say!
If she hadn’t written House of Mirth I probably wouldn’t read another word by or about her but I so loved that book. I have both the Wharton and the Woolf bio out from the library.
Stefanie! You have oodles of time to read her fiction now that the bio time is through.
I hadn’t read anything of Wharton other than Ethan Frome (which we read in high school) until this year when I read Age of Innocence and House of Mirth both of which I thought were splendid. I love biography, and have grown to love Wharton, so this book sounds perfect. Very big to tote around, though. Definitely arm chair reading.
Excellent review! I have it at home and definitely will read it. As for her works, I liked “Ethan Fromme” and “The House of Mirth,” but “The Age of Innocence” blew me away. Fantastic book. Also worth a look is her autobiography, “A Backward Glance.”
When you make that trip to Concord one day, be sure to head over to the Berkshires to visit Wharton’s home, The Mount: http://www.edithwharton.org/index.php?catId=6. There, you can visit the library that Lee apparently does a great job in describing. And it’s just down the road from Melville’s home, Arrowhead, where he would sit on his piazza day after day and look, for inspiration for the book he was writing, over to a mountain off in the distance that reminded him of a whale…
Emily, thanks! Wharton’s books and libraries sound amazing. I like how her direction for decorating a library was that the shelves should be background and the books should take centerstage. I could hug her for that. I’d like to read her Cather bio too and the couple of books she has on writing biography.
Kathleen, *gasp* I don’t know what to say about your confession
There are plenty of big name writers I haven’t read. There are simply too many good books to read and not enough time to read them all. I don’t think anyone’s reading life will be less for not having read Wharton. She is quite good, however, and if you do decided to give her a whiel sometime I hope you enjoy her!
Carrie, House of Mirth is a fantastic book. If you read both the Wharton and Woolf bio you will be busy for quite some time. Oodles of time, oodles and oodles
Grad, you know, I’ve not read Age of Innocence? Not sure why. That’s one I need to get to. And yeah, the Wharton bio is definitely armchair reading, not one you want to lug around in your bag.
Rizwan, thanks! Lee frequently mentions Backward Glance and how it both reveals and conceals Wharton’s life. I forget how close together things are in New England. I could manage quite a number of literary visits in a rather short time. Isn’t Mark Twain’s house out there somewhere too? And Hawthorne and the Alcotts, and…I might come and never leave!
I will have to find that Wharton biography; you have me intrigued. I have enjoyed her novels– Ethan Frome, House of Mirth, Age of Innocence, but also The Buccaneers, her last novel.
If you like biographies of authors you might be interested in Mary Henley Rubio’s bio. of L.M. Montgomery, called The Gift of Wings.
I would love to read this and must add it to my wishlist. I always think I should read more of an author’s work, though, before reading their biography (fear of learning too much about books I’ve not yet read). And I totally understand how some books just take longer to read–I have that same problem myself!
What an interesting post, Stefanie. I’ve thoroughly enjoyed reading it. Your mention of Liam Neeson’s version of Ethan Frome stirs up some vague memories… I think I’d seen it, ages ago. That’s the only EW book I’ve read. I’ve also enjoyed the film The Age of Innocence but have yet read the book. After reading all these posts on EW, I feel I must read more of her works, probably the short story A Journey first, from the link over at Whispering Gums. Again, thanks for a wonderful write-up on HL’s book.
Joanne, if you like Wharton you will definitely enjoy the biography. And thanks for the tip on the L.M. MOntgomery bio!
Danielle, I always think that too but I plunged in anyway. While Lee does pretty much give away the plots of the books and stories she talks about I figure that by the time I actually get around to reading them I will have forgotten
Arti, thanks for your kind words. Lee certainly made me sympathetic to Wharton in a number of ways and she stirred up my interest to read the books and stories especially the ones for which is isn’t well-known. Wharton was quite prolific yet we only remember her for a small amount of her work.
Pingback: 2010 in Review | So Many Books