The Persimmon Tree and Other Stories by Marjorie Barnard is a collection of stories that often left me breathless. Some of them even have a sort of Flannery O’Connor feel to them, an every day, unsentimental piece of life with an ending I didn’t see coming that leaves me with a feeling akin to being punched in the stomach. I don’t like being punched in the stomach in general, but when a book does it, it makes me happy, which reveals my secret book masochist self. Not all stories are like that, just enough to notice. Other stories were just plain sad and sometimes left me crying.
Many of the stories are about women. Take, for instance, “Beauty is Strength.” A woman goes into a beauty salon to have her hair done. These days we tend to think of salons more like spas, places we go to be pampered. But this is Australia sometime in the 1950s where a beauty salon is not a spa but where women go to armor themselves against the signs of aging. There is a distinct power differential between the women who work in the salon and the women who go there for services. The women who work there know of all the physical flaws of the women who come in. They know how gray their hair is, the flaws that are hidden by makeup and stylish clothes. A woman sitting under the hair dryer, devoid of makeup and surrounded by mirrors sees the truth about her face, is forced to notice the wrinkles and other ravages of time.
Several stories are about marriage. In “It Will Grow Anywhere” we learn that even the perfect wife is not safe, that she can actually be so perfect her husband decides to divorce her. “The Lottery” is about a woman who wins £5,000 in the Australian lottery. She doesn’t call her husband at work to tell him, he finds out from friends on the way home from work who had read about it in the paper. He wonders where his wife got the money to even buy a ticket and begins accusing her in his mind because he is sure she must have somehow stolen it from the money he gives her to run the house. While his anger at his wife grows, he imagines how he might spend the money.
Then there are the stories that are devastating like “The Hat.” Gwenda’s children decide their mother needs a new hat. Her current one is old and shabby. They send her to an upscale shop and tell her to choose whatever she wants and to not worry about the price. Gwenda is thrilled. She sees a beautiful hat, stylish and jaunty, tells the saleswoman she’d like to try it on. The saleswoman says no, that is not a hat for her, she has something more suitable in the back. While the saleswoman is away, Gwenda makes the mistake of trying on the hat.
The most devastating story of all, however, was one called “Fighting in Vienna.” It takes place in Vienna during WWI. Kathie is a young woman who lives all alone, her family either dead or off fighting in the war. She needs to go out one afternoon to get some seed for her bird who continues to sing despite everything. I have to leave it at that because I am starting to cry just typing this.
The author of The Persimmon Tree and Other Stories, Marjorie Barnard, is Australian and was quite the writer in her day and, in my opinion, should be given more attention, especially in the U.S. where her books are hard to find. The edition of the book I read is a Virago for all you Virago fans out there.
I’m counting this book as the first completion in the Bloglily Summer Reading Program. The category it falls under is “recommended by a librarian” (that would be Whispering Gums). Under the rules of the program I am also supposed to suggest a readalike. I have two suggestions: A Good Man is Hard to Find by Flannery O’Connor, and the short stories of Kate Chopin (10 pts). I also checked the book out from my library (10 pts), wrote about it (10 pts), and wrote it down in my Program Booklet (10 pts). I’m up 40 points already. Woo! I really want to win a boomerang.
The book sounds really good, and anything that you can compare to O’Connor is going to get my attention.
Oh, I’m SO-O-O glad you liked (if that’s the word!) this book. I’ve read it twice and could read it again. The stories are stunning I think … and make you think about all the nuances going on. They are of their time (the details of the way things were) and yet universal as well (the emotions). Barnard suffered at the hands of men – father who didn’t support/encourage her, lover (another writer) who left her. No wonder, I think, that she’s so astute, particularly about the challenges of life!
A great review, makes me want to read the book straight away – I’m a bit worried for my heart though, I get a feeling of much sadness and melancholy here?
Dorothy, it is really good. It doesn’t have O’Connor’s religious undetones, but it’s subjects are domestic and unsentimental. Barnard shoots from the hip as it were.
Whisperinggums, and thank you for bringing this marvelous book to my attention! The stories are indeed stunning. I am not surprised to hear Barnard suffered at the hands of men. The men don’t always come out looking so well in the stories.
Sigrun, thanks! There is a lot of sadness and melancholy in the stories but the book as a whole did not leave me feeling sad if that helps at all.
yes, it does! its summer – i try to save up most of the sadness for those long, dark and cold winter months
What an interesting writer she sounds! So it’s get the book and a kingsize box of tissues to go, yes?
I’ll certainly look out for her and see if she’s made it over here.
She sounds like a wonderful writer and these stories quite good. I have some Alice Munro stories on my stack of things to read and think it would be interesting to compare the two. Also — I’d say this is totally boomerang-worthy.
Litlove, only a couple stories made me cry, so you could get away with a small travel-size packet of tissues
Bloglily, I’ve not read Alice Munro but I have heard wonderful things about her. I’d be interested to hear how she compares. Even more boomerang-worthy since the book is Australian
I actually own this one! I have a Virago edition. May have to dig it out–if nothing else than to look at it and now I will probably like it very much. Am very interested in the story set in Vienna, though am not in the mood to cry at the moment! I’m only partially in to my first B-SLURP (See Bloglily’s most recent post) book. I didn’t realize there was a boomerang for a prize….must read faster.
Sounds awesome. I’m always looking for good short story collections to expand my horizons, since I typically don’t choose to read short stories.
Danielle, it’s a good one to own. I suspect you will like it very much. Bloglily did not promise a boomerang as a prize but it is a possibility along with cars and cash prizes
Emily, I don’t usually choose to read short stories either but lately I seem to be reading quite a lot of them and so far they are all good. Persimmon Tree is well worth a read.
Pingback: Swimming in Short Stories | So Many Books