In the mood for science? Biography? A graphic novel? Then you may want to read Feynman written by Jim Ottaviani and drawn by Leland Myrick. It is a fairly recent publication and will probably find itself ranked up there among the best graphic novels available. Except it isn’t a novel. So what is a graphic novel that isn’t a novel called?
The book is a whirlwind tour of the life and work of Richard Feynman, Nobel Prize winner in physics and a great teacher and personality. The book begins in 1964 with Feynman giving a lecture to a packed hall, then skips back to 1923 when Feynman was a boy and his dad is reading him a bedtime story. Then we jump ahead to 1986 and back to 1927. But none of this is confusing and all the jumping around serves to show how past influenced future. Then there is a good long stretch in the middle that is chronological with Feynman in high school, falling in love, going off to MIT, and beginning his work on Quantum Electrodynamics Theory (QED). The theory belonged to the scientist Dirac but it wasn’t complete and Feynman wanted to figure out how to fill in the gaps. He filled in some but not all of the gaps, graduated with a Ph.D. and then shelved his work on the theory for awhile because his fiance, soon wife, became ill with tuberculosis and he was asked to go work at Los Alamos during WWII. He was part of the group that created the atomic bomb.
During his time at Los Alamos, he also taught himself how to be a safecracker. His wife died on June 16, 1945. He was grief stricken but instead of mourning her loss, he threw himself into his work. Not until a year later, after the war, when he arrived at Cornell to take up teaching was he finally able to allow himself to cry.
He was unable to produce any new work for quite sometime. One day he decided he just needed to play like he did when he was younger and not worry about whether what he was doing was important or not. So he began trying to figure out the motion of a rotating plate tossed into the air and the wobble that happened in that motion. This led him back to QED. At the same time there were two other men working on solving QED, Julian Schwinger and Sin-Itiro Tomonaga. They all became aware of the work each was doing and while they didn’t actually collaborate, they did work off of each other and between the three of them they completed QED. For this the three of them shared the Nobel Prize in 1965.
Besides a brilliant physicist, Feynman was also a gifted teacher. He was determined to be able to explain QED to people who were not students or physicists. It took him a long time to be able to do it because, as he explained, even physicists didn’t know why QED worked. But he managed to do it in a series of lectures that he first delivered in New Zealand. They have been printed in a book called QED: The Strange Theory of Light and Matter, or, through the magic of the internet, you can watch him deliver the lectures. If you have time for neither, QED is nicely explained– with pictures!– in the graphic novel. It takes work to follow and is kind of mind-bendy, but it is not impossible.
Feynman eventually goes to teach at Cal Tech in California, remarries and has children. After the Challenger exploded in 1986, he was asked to be on the investigative commission. He was the only one who was not afraid to speak out about the O-ring failure and the other issues at NASA that contributed to the disaster. He wrote a separate report of his own because he could not in good conscious sign his name to the report that the commission wrote. A big argument ensued but a compromise was struck and Feynman signed the commission report and his report was placed, in full, in the appendix. When the report was made public, most people did not even talk about the part the commission wrote but went straight to Feynman’s report.
Feynman died in 1988 from cancer. He had a long and distinguished career and was well-loved by friends, colleagues and students.
Graphic form is well-suited to telling Feynman’s life story. Feynman himself was a visual thinker and would often imagine what the math and theories looked like. He drew pictures and diagrams and some of his QED diagrams are included in the book and they are excellent at helping explain the theory. And while the book is excellent, it is made even more top-drawer by the inclusion of an annotated bibliography. And it is great that this was included because believe me, after reading the graphic novel, if you are like me, you will want to find out more and the bibliography provides a fantastic place to start.
I’ve never seen a graphic novel that is actually sort of a biography–I like the sound of it. Somehow it seems like it would make science more approachable in graphic form? Must check it out!
Yes, an amazing guy, a bit of an inspiration. Did the book treat his famous O-ring demonstration before Congress of the Challenger disaster?
There are other graphic “books” that aren’t fiction aren’t there? It feels because they’re not pure text they must somehow be less “factual” but I realise that when I think about it logically, there’s no reason why there can’t be graphic biographies, graphic histories?
Anyhow, I’d like to read this. I did read “Surely You’re Joking, Mr. Feynman!”: Adventures of a Curious Character. I remember enjoying it immensely. Fascinating and rather charismatic character it seems.
Thank you so much for this. I am definitely going to look it up tomorrow evening at the bookstore. I just absolutely love reading about scientists, but sometimes I get bogged down in the technical data presented. No matter how many times I have read of Schrodinger’s cat or Einstein’s experiments with light particles, I still don;t quite GET IT!
This graphically presented book about Feynman sounds like something that would definitely enthrall me ad infinitum.
I’ve only read a few graphic novels and this sounds like another to add to my list. What a fascinating man and life!
Well now, this afternoon, I’ll be seeing students in the Dirac Room, as Dirac used to be at my college. It’s a nice room, actually! Am I dreaming it or did Feynman write some essays himself? I’ve got a feeling I gave them to Mister Litlove many years ago.
Danielle, it does indeed make the science less intimidating. I think Feynman would approve.
Richard, yes indeed, the book does the o-ring experiment though Feynman didn’t get to do it at the moment he wanted to and it was a bit less dramatic than he had wanted it to be. He was quite the showman!
whisperinggums, yes, there are graphic memoirs for sure, and probably other graphic genres too. I fall into the trap sometimes of thinking that graphic means dumbed down but the more books I read like Feynman the less I fall into that trap. I plan on reading “Surely You’re Joking” eventually and he apparently has a book about how to cope with having only average intelligence which he would not know about from personal experience but which I suspect might be a fun read.
Cipriano, I love reading about scientists and science too, especially physics. You will definitely like Feynman. It pretty much leaves out the math but still explains QED quite well. And I learned something about light and photons and electrons that I didn’t know before!
Kathleen, definitely one to add to your list!
Litlove, what a coincidence! Feynman wrote several books. I think the one you might be thinking of is “Surely You’re Joking Mr. Feynman?” If your son is the science-y type I suspect he’d like this and Mr. Litlove too.
Yes, and I think the thing about the best graphic works is their interplay between text and image, and some of them have stunning (if not always “beautiful”) art work. I suddenly discovered a whole new sophisticated world when my son introduced me to graphic novels when he was a teen (because of course I had just thought they were longer comics).
I agree, the artwork is often stunning and so perfectly suited to telling that particular story. I used to think they were long comic books too but about the time Persepolis came out decided that maybe I should look at a few of them before dismissing them. I am so glad I did because it is now a genre I would hate to not include in my reading from time to time.
I read Surely You’re Joking, Mr. Feynman a couple of years ago and enjoyed it thoroughly. A fascinating and multi-talented man with a wonderful outlook on life!
Ooo, this sounds really good. I’ve been meaning to read about Feynman and to try to understand his theories for years (yes, really), and a graphic biography sounds like a good place to start.
I’m wondering when book classifiers are going to drop the “novel” that seems automatically to appear after “graphic.” So much of what’s graphic isn’t fiction. I find that I tend to enjoy graphic memoirs most, especially when they’re both written and illustrated by the same person. I haven’t yet read a graphic biography. Maybe this should be the first?
“Surely, You’re Joking” and his other works were a great joy for me to read as an engineer/scientist, but I imagine they would be approachable for many readers. I really liked his explanation of how a school with a patched together accelerator was winning prizes in research over better funded schools with more expensive equipment.
This ‘graphic biography’ sounds interesting.
Jenclair, he does seem like such a fun and funny person. I am definitely going to have to read Surely You’re Joking!
Emily, I totally thought of you when I was reading this. You would definitely like it. It is hard to drop the “novel” part from graphic since most people know what a graphic novel is but might be confused about what a graphic biography is. Maybe? Your library probably has this one and if you read it you will find yourself wanting to foist it on your patrons
Bikkuri, I must have been living under a rock that so many have read “Surely You’re Joking” and I haven’t. I am going to have to rectify that. No doubt you would enjoy the graphic biorgraphy is you are able to get your hands on it sometime.
Wow! I had no idea that there was a graphic bio of Feynman!! He is such an inspiring figure. I especially like his way of thinking about (and explaining) things from first principles with easy-to-comprehend concepts, and then putting these things together in creative ways. No unnecessary jargon at all.
Among his books, I really liked Six Easy Pieces, which is well within the grasp of most people. Another beautiful book is The Character of Physical Law. I haven’t read QED yet, but suspect that it is going to be harder conceptually than the previous two.
I’m getting this graphic bio pronto. Thanks a lot for sharing this; If this is even half as good as Logicomix, I’m going to have a whale of a time!