It’s been a wonderful Bookman birthday day today. The cake came out so good and it couldn’t have been simpler. It is basically a single-layer chocolate cake with some cherries in it topped with a can of cherry pie filling and then drizzled with chocolate. What could be easier? And because of the cherries we can pretend that it is nutritious!
I began reading My Poets by Maureen McLane today and very quickly became friends with this book.
The first chapter is short and is a “Proem in the form of a Q&A” Here is a sample:
Why do you read poetry?
I caught this morning morning’s minion.Why do you read poetry?
Batter my heart.Why to you read poetry?
I have wasted my life.
Other questions include what is the first poem you remember, why poetry, and why do you write poetry? Here are a couple answers to the last question:
Why do you write poetry?
My purpose here is to advance into
the sense of the weather.Why do you write poetry?
I sing to use the Waiting.
As if that weren’t marvelous enough, chapter two muses about the word “kankedort” which apparently only appears in Chaucer’s Troilus and Criseyde. From there we move to a chapter called “My Impasses” in which McLane talks about two poetry classes she took as a college freshman in 1985, one of them taught by Helen Vendler. She talks about reading poetry and reading poetry, good readings and bad readings, about finding a way into a poem and being stuck on the outside even though you badly want to understand. And she talks about how, years later, a poem that was so confusing and impossible originally can suddenly open up and let you in and mean so much. It is a really wonderful chapter that I might have to reread and write about because she says so much that is true.
And then chapter four. Oh, I had to stop myself in the middle of it so I wouldn’t rush to the end because it is so utterly fun. Chapter four is called “My Elizabeth Bishop / (My Gertrude Stein)” and it is written in the style of Stein. For her undergraduate thesis McLane decided she was going to write about Stein but Stein resisted her and a gift from a mentor of a book of Elizabeth Bishop poems turned out to be a wonderful discovery and saved her thesis from disaster. I must give you a taste of the chapter so here is how it begins:
My Elizabeth Bishop begins with Gertrude Stein.
This is not usual.
Bishop is unusual but not in the way Stein is unusual.
I was not used to Gertrude Stein and found I could not get used
to Stein though I tried.
I was struggling to find a topic for my undergraduate thesis.
This seemed the most important thing in the world.
Whatever is the world to you is the most important thing to
you.
I would be making myself in this thing.
I was always making myself or being made.
This was unavoidable.
I was planning on being made by Gertrude Stein but she was not
cooperating.
She was operating on another plane a fractured cubist grid I
could not make out.
And it appears to go on like this for entire 27 pages of the chapter.
I suppose this kind of book might not be for everyone, but oh, I have a little crush on it at the moment and hope that we manage to be best friends by the final page.
I have just started reading it, too, and I am thoroughly entranced. I enjoy reading literary criticism, especially about poetry, but this book just feels so, I don’t know, “real” and accesible in a way that is wonderful. And I don’t really think “criticism” is the right term. It definitely crosses those literary lines in the sand. Perhaps that’s the whole point. Anyway, loving it!
Maureen, someone else who is falling in love with the book! You are right, it is criticism but not really and feels so fresh and accessible. It is very exciting.
Happy Birthday, Bookman. Cherries are very good anti-oxidants, so eat without guilt, if you need an excuse (which one should NOT need on one’s birthday) I have never been a poetry reader, except for what I was required to read in school. But I do like and appreciate good poetry. I’m afraid rather than encounter it, it encounters me…meaning I usually stumble upon it when I don’t expect it. Poetry takes practice…and patience – at least for me.
Grad, Bookman asked me to convey his thanks. Oh yes, all those anti-oxidants, but you are right, birthdays need no excuses! I think you are not alone in your relationship with poetry. It takes practice and patience for everyone, even those of us who love to read it and do so regularly.
I have to get a copy of this NOW! I was sold at the first Hopkins quote. I want it.
Alex, oh yes, it is fantastic. I borrowed mine from the library but I might have to buy a copy for my shelf.
My library doesn’t have a copy. Much gnashing of teeth.
Oh no! Maybe they have bought a copy or will buy one. I hope so!
It’s such a wonderful feeling when a book takes you by the collar and whisks you away! So glad you are loving it and a very happy birthday to the Bookman.
Litlove, it is a wonderful feeling and for as much as we read it seems to happen infrequently. But when it does, oh glorious! Bookman says thanks for the birthday wishes!
I am so getting this for my mom for Christmas…then I can read it too.
pburt, brilliant plan! I do that to my husband sometimes, buy him books that I also want to read. I feel only a little guilty because he does the same!
I’m glad the birthday went well! The book sounds really interesting — something I might just like very much. Thanks for the introduction!
Rebecca, thanks! And yes, I think My Poets could be a book you would like quite a lot.
This sounds like the perfect book for you! Someone shared this link (and this online course) with me…I might just do it:
https://www.coursera.org/course/modernpoetry
It’s free and it might be a good way for me to get into poetry! I was hoping you were going to share a photo of your cake–it sounds yummy and the cherries definitely make it practically a health food. Was it dark chocolate, too?
Danielle, the more I read in this book the more I like it. I am going to buy a copy for myself for sure. That class looks like fun! A survey course is always a good way to learn about poetry in general and get a wide sampling of lots of different poets and learn what you like and don’t like. Then from there is gets easier to branch out and also dive deeper. If you have the time and inclination, give it try! Sorry I didn’t post a photo of the cake. The chocolate is vegan chocolate chips which are on the dark side
I need to get this book too! Thanks for the wonderful beginning review
Isn’t it wonderful when you fall in love with a book that talks to you about poetry, or a book you love, or an author, or a kind of writing?
Susan, oh yes, it is wonderful to fall in love with a book of any kind but one that makes you love other books even more is extra special. Sorry your library doesn’t have it. I hope you will be able to get your paws on a copy. The more of it I read, the more I like it.
Drat. Our library doesn’t have it. Will have to see if I can order it. This sounds so very interesting.
Oh dear, I’m behind in properly reading your blog. Love this post. Love “I caught this morning morning’s minion” (from my favourite poet of all time, really). What great answers to why do you read poetry. Batter my heart. I have wasted my life!
What would my answer be?
Perhaps Eliot’s “I have measured out my life with coffee spoons” which is a bit in the “I have wasted my life” vein. But, maybe it’s a little more negative than I’d like.
So, hmm … Perhaps from Dorothy Porter,
“Life is so dangerous”.
Who better than the poets to help us traverse our lives!