I so very much enjoyed Braiding Sweetgrass : Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge, and the Teachings of Plants by Robin Wall Kimmerer. It’s one of those nebulous genre books, nonfiction to be sure, but it is nature writing, science, botany, Native American history and stories, and memoir and it all flows together so smoothly like a braid of sweetgrass. What the book is really about at its heart though is storytelling: the story of plants, the story of a people, the story of a person, the story of how we treat the environment, the story of origins and the stories of possible futures. And beyond that is how these stories make their way out into the world and affect how individuals and groups see themselves and their environment.
Kimmerer is a citizen of the Potawatami Nation. She is also a professor of environmental biology at the University of New York at Syracuse. She has a really interesting way of looking at the environment through a blended lens of science and indigenous American teachings and beliefs which can be surprisingly complimentary.
Braiding Sweetgrass begins with the story of Skywoman, a creation story. In it Skywoman fell from a hole in the Skyworld and below her was a place of dark water. But the Geese saw her falling and flew up to catch her but they could not hold her forever. A council was held and a great Turtle volunteered to hold Skywoman on his back. They all knew she needed land. So Otter, Beaver and Sturgeon volunteered to swim to the depths of the water to bring back mud, but none of them could do it. Things were looking dire until little Muskrat volunteered. He was gone for a very long time and then his limp body rose to the surface. In Muskrat’s paw was a small handful of mud. He had given his life for Skywoman. Skywoman spread the mud on Turtle’s back and began to dance and sing in thanksgiving for all the gifts the animals had given her. As she danced the land became larger and larger and that is why the world is called Turtle Island.
Skywoman also brought gifts with her. When she fell she had reached out and grabbed a branch of the Tree of Life and so came with fruits and seeds which she planted and tended. Soon the land was abundant with food and medicine for both Skywoman and the animals.
There is more to the story but you get the idea. Now, Kimmerer says, compare this story to that of Adam and Eve exiled from the garden. In the western tradition there is a hierarchy of beings and humans are at the top, we are in charge and we have the right to do whatever we want to the earth. In indigenous teachings, humans are the younger brothers of Creation, we are the ones who have the most to learn and so need to pay attention to what animals and plants have to teach us.
Throughout the book Kimmerer asks us to consider how these stories encourage us and teach us to look at the world and our relationship to it. But she is also careful to say that she does not want everyone following indigenous teachings, that would not be right. What she believes needs to happen is new stories need to be told that encourage healing, gratitude and reciprocity with nature and the world. What those stories are she cannot say, they are ones we have to create together.
There are stories in the book that made my heart hurt. Stories of her grandfather being taken away from his family when he was a boy and put in a boarding school where he was not allowed to speak his native language or follow his people’s teachings. Stories about environmental destruction and how the law seems to have its hands tied in making companies clean up their poison. But there are also stories that made me laugh, inspired me and gave me hope.
Braiding Sweetgrass is a lovely book suffused with Kimmerer’s patient, gentle voice. If you are looking for something a little different that focuses on the environment, then I can’t recommend it enough.
Wonderful review, Stefanie. I hate to admit this is probably one I would not necessarily have put on my radar had it not been for your review. I really liked this: “new stories need to be told that encourage healing, gratitude and reciprocity with nature and the world.” I think the world could certainly use this!
LikeLike
Iliana, thanks! I wouldn’t have read it either except one day I was browsing the library catalog and saw the title and requested it thinking it was about gardening and natural medicine and herb growing! A marvelous accidental discovery.
LikeLike
I completely agree with iliana’s comment. will put this book
on the list!
LikeLike
booksandbuttons, thanks! I hope you enjoy it should you read it!
LikeLike
It sounds like a book I would like very much too. The creation myth is beautiful. Can I ask, apart from the joy it gave you reading it which is evident in your review, (how) has it influenced your looking at your garden?
LikeLike
Cath, I think you would like the book very much. I could write a very long answer to your question! But in short, yes, it has influenced how I look at my garden. She has encouraged me to see the garden as a gift exchange and a place of mutual love between me and the earth. I give care and attention and love to my garden and in return the earth/garden loves me back and gives me food and flowers which I also share with friends and neighbors and animals who give me gifts in return. It creates a web of giving, gratitude and mutual care. I’ve never thought about it like that before but it makes a big shift in my relationship to my garden and everything that surrounds it.
LikeLike
I do love this kind of hybrid non-fiction. I expect this one will take a while to reach Britist shelves, alas, but I’ll look out for it.
LikeLike
Litlove, I do too, when done well it is so very enjoyable. This one is very American but I do hope it makes its way outside the borders.
LikeLike
I like that she says it’s not that we should believe in Native American stories but that we need our own stories to teach us.
Her Gathering Moss book has science as a much more central focus, but is still informed by her spirituality. I’m glad to hear you liked this one- I think she is an author who deserves to be much better known.
LikeLike
biblioglobal, yes, I am glad she stressed that because I think it is important, cultural appropriation is never good even when well meant. I plan on reading Gathering Moss sometime since I liked this book so much and you have spoken so highly about it.
LikeLike
What a wonderful review. I’m looking for books like this one. Because of your review, I placed this on hold at the library.
LikeLike
Vasilly, thanks! I hope you enjoy the book!
LikeLike
I love the title, and I enjoy books that introduce mythology and provoke thought about cultural similarities and differences concerning the origin and impact of the myth on current beliefs. I also tend to prefer memoirs that have to do with nature and/or gardening–they always seem to have a positive approach to life.
LikeLike
jenclair, isn’t it a great title? And of course she writes a lot about sweetgrass the plant from both a science and cultural perspective. It’s fascinating. I think from what you say regarding books you like, you would definitely like this one.
LikeLike
Sounds like a much better reading experience than the last! 🙂 I like the sound of this and want to read more nature-oriented books. Sounds like a nice combination of genres (?–not sure what to call them). I will add it to my wishlist!
LikeLike
Danielle, most definitely! It is a really wonderful combination of genres. I’m going to have to find more books that do that I think!
LikeLike
Pingback: Vital Signs | So Many Books
Pingback: On and Off Topic | So Many Books