When I first began reading Famous Modern Ghost Stories I mentioned how much fun Dorothy Scarborough’s introduction was. Turns out, the stories themselves are fun too.
There are fifteen stories in this collection. Some of them, like Poe’s “Ligeia,” I have read before. Some it really felt like I had read before but I couldn’t recall when or where, like “The Willows” by Algernon Blackwood (I just love the name Algernon, it’s so, I’m not sure what, but it tickles my fancy so it is probably good I don’t have kids because I’d be tempted to call a boy Algernon and then you know he’d go by “Algie” for short and all the kids at school would make fun of him). Others were plain silly like “At the Gate” by Myla Jo Closser in which a recently deceased dog takes up his vigil outside the gates of Heaven with the other dogs waiting for their owners to arrive.
My favorite story in the collection was “Lazarus” by Leonid Andreyev. It is the story of Lazarus after he was raised from the dead. Did you ever see the Buffy the Vampire Slayer show where they bring Buffy back from the dead? She kind of wasn’t the same afterwards, or at least for a while. Well, Lazarus wasn’t the same either and while everyone was really glad to have him back, the haunting look in his eyes kind of freaked people out so no one wanted to be around him. Maybe if Lazarus had had a Scooby gang he would have eventually recovered.
Coming in second as my favorite story based only on the complete absurdity of it all, was “The Beast with Five Fingers” by W.F. Harvey. Bachelor uncle is ill and Eustace, while visiting, notices that uncle is unconsciously doing automatic writing. Eustace goofs around with this a bit until uncle dies. And then, in spite of uncle’s wishes to be cremated, he is not. Last minute instructions turn up and Eustace is bequeathed uncle’s well-preserved hand, the hand with which he did the automatic writing! The hand, of course, is alive but it isn’t uncle inhabiting it. At one point Eustace locks the hand in a desk drawer and the hand writes a note and slips it out through a crack in the desk. A servant finds a note bidding him to open the desk drawer and when the servant does so, the hand escapes! It is never clear why Eustace is being haunted by this hand or what the hand’s intent is, but the story comes very close to being a farce, right up to and including the hand eventually strangling Eustace and then the two of them ultimately perishing in a fire.
After reading so many ghost stories together it seems there is almost a requirement that at least one person experiencing the ghost or other phenomena has to be utterly and completely unbelieving. He, because it is usually a he in these stories, is then required to make up all sorts of logical explanations for what is happening. These explanations often approach the ridiculous. In the end, however, the unbeliever is convinced by the haunting and is either just in time to save himself or too late and dies. A few do believe right away and these have two responses. The smart ones figure out what the ghost wants. The not so smart ones go into battle. The smart ones generally come through unscathed and even satisfied about having helped a spirit move on. The not smart ones usually end up dead or psychologically traumatized for the rest of their lives.
These stories, even the bad ones, are all amusing in their own way. Of course I’m not supposed to be amused, I am supposed to get chills. But it seems that much of what haunts us is related to the times in which we live. Not that we can’t still feel a tingle down the spine when reading Poe, but it isn’t going to keep us up at night. Which makes me wonder whether in 100 years readers will think Stephen King is scary or will readers of the distant future read him and giggle and wonder why the twin girls in The Shining scare us so badly and make their way into other places like this IKEA commercial:
As a RIP Challenge read, Famous Modern Ghost Stories was quite fun. If you are looking for some older stories that don’t tend to show up in the anthologies, this would be a good choice.
Anyone who comes back from the dead comes back wrong. This is not only the idea behind my blog name but one of my most deeply-held beliefs.
LikeLike
Jeanne, well then if you haven’t read the story Lazarus, it is one you would find pretty interesting!
LikeLike
Stefanie, this is ingenious! The IKEA ad I mean. And no, I don’t think people will think it’s laughable 100 yrs. down the road. There’s something inherently eerie in children being ghostly and even children’s laughs can be so haunting when put into a horror genre context. Here in the ad, its maker is doing this as a parody but an effective one. I was feeling the chills. Glad it’s Mom and Dad on the other side calling and not the twins. And The Shining remains one of the scariest movies I’ve ever seen. But of course, I haven’t seen many since that’s the genre I usually avoid. 😉
LikeLike
I think absurdity is never very far away with stories about the supernatural- just think of the Gothic fiction sent up in Northanger Abbey! The fascination of the ghost story is its difficulty and a few writers do manage to avoid unintentional humour ( and surely a ghost story that makes you smile has essentially failed). Le Fanu, MR James, Henry James, Shirley Jackson, Walter De La Mare are writers who really make the ghost story work.
LikeLike
Ian, I think you are right, there is a fine line between the scary and absurd which makes things like ghost stories so hard to pull off.
LikeLike
Arti, isn’t it a good ad? IKEA is on a role with their ads lately, first the Book Book and now this. The Shining is definitely one of the scariest movies I have ever seen. it gave me nightmares and I have never dared read the book because I figured that would be even scarier!
LikeLike
Aw, “Ligeia”! Gosh I haven’t thought of that story in years. I once wrote an excellent paper on “Ligeia,” and my insecure-yet-hard-to-please English professor gave me a 97 on it. (Man, I sometimes really miss the constant feedback you get from being in school.)
LikeLike
Jenny, heh, that was the benefit of being in school, wasn’t it? You always had an idea of where you stood.
LikeLike
Thanks for the recommendation! I’m in a Halloween-ish mood, and so will be sure to check out this collection.
LikeLike
Rae, I hope you enjoy the collection. And I am glad you liked the IKEA ad!
LikeLike
PS: Love the IKEA ad!
LikeLike
I’ve just been sent a book for SNB that’s an anthology of Victorian ghost stories – I instantly thought of you and Danielle! I’d send it over but it’s hardback and the cost is prohibitive. I’ll have to see if I can twist a publisher’s arm! This sounds patchy but fun, and it is the perfect time of year for it!
LikeLike
Litlove, thanks for the thought! Even though these old ghost stories are really no longer scary, they still have high entertainment value. 🙂
LikeLike
Hmm–Litlove you must give us the title at least! 🙂 This sounds like a fun collection and I am noting it down for next year. I think my ghost story reading is mostly finished for the year (am ready to move on to something new), but I might take a peek and squeeze one in for the holidays later this year.
LikeLike
Danielle, I am sure you would love this collection. You can read it on your iPad at the gym 🙂
LikeLike
Pingback: The Willows